Steve was nice enough to accompany me to Julie and Julia last night, which was great because we got to bash it the whole way home.
The movie made me angry at our generation, or rather at the depiction of our generation. It made Julia Child look authentic: strange, towering, loud, energetic, original with big dreams. Julie, the blogger who cooks her way through Julia Child’s cookbook in one year, is whiny, skinny, and smaller than life. Julia’s kitchen is gorgeous; Julie’s kitchen is rusty and claustrophobic. Julia is in love with her husband; Julie’s love for her husband feels spastic, sporadic, and false. Julie spends too much time in front of the computer, chatting on her blog. Julia is writing a cookbook on a typewriter with carbon copy sheets and real paper. Julie is ‘publishing’ without editing, degrading the language with drivel. She isn’t funny or original, and at the end, when she wants everyone to be proud of her for cooking so much, it feels like a huge setback: she wants me to be proud of her, not for creating a cookbook, not for creating anything, but for copying? for cooking recipes that someone else made and then telling people about it? It made our generation seem incredibly trite and intensely, disappointingly derivative.
The premise has a lovely form: two women with similar names find themselves through food, at the beginning of one girl’s adult life and at the end of another’s. The girl looks to her role model to learn how to be a woman. But she never does anything further than copy in a lesser form what the older woman made. And in the end we learn that Julia Child was uninterested in Julie’s blog project. Just as anyone would be uninterested if I typed out the books I love instead of writing my own. There is so much to be said for the lessons in imitation, but we hope that we learn to stand on the shoulders of giants to reach further than the giants could reach. I have to believe that that’s true.
I love the intimacy of the blog form. It is private and personal and has so much room to be whatever the writer needs it to be. I love the string the reader follows, as if it were an old-fashioned mystery we read in installments. I think many blogs can be beautiful, and I think that our generation is capable of more than any other generation before. It hurt me to see a young woman celebrated for copying someone else’s recipes in a less authentic form, in a less authentic space, with less authentic language to describe them. I am writing this on a blog: I have to believe that our era holds more than Julie in her ugly kitchen can see.
August 15th, 2009 | Category: overheard | Leave a comment